All Projects

How can statistical analysis evaluate the impact of voter ID laws?

Providing expert testimony on voter ID laws

America has passed laws for decades that restrict the ability of eligible voters to vote. In many cases, these laws have disproportionally affected racial and ethnic minorities.

How can Westat's data collection and statistical capabilities be used to determine when laws are discriminatory ?

Westat’s David Marker, Ph.D., Associate Director and Senior Statistician, testified as an expert witness in 3 court cases before both federal and state courts. In each case, the state passed a law that required possession of one of a very limited set of photo identifications.

Texas. To show that it did not discriminate against minority groups, Texas conducted a very poor quality telephone survey. Dr. Marker testified as an expert witness on behalf of the local National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) and Mexican-American Legal Defense Fund. His testimony before the U.S. Federal Court of Appeals demonstrated the low quality of the survey and that it did not approach the standards expected for data used by the federal government. Quoting this testimony, the Court threw out the survey and stated that, as a result, the State of Texas had not demonstrated the law did not discriminate.

Pennsylvania. The plaintiffs conducted a survey demonstrating disparate impact on minorities and by geography. The state judge had thrown out the survey. Testifying at a re-hearing, Dr. Marker demonstrated that the survey was of reasonable quality and could be relied upon for analysis. The survey was admitted as evidence, and the judge ruled the law invalid.

Alabama. To demonstrate how the law impacted Black and Hispanic registered voters, Westat was asked to conduct a survey of registered voters whose names and addresses did not match driver’s licenses (and non-voter IDs) maintained by the state. The survey demonstrated that Black registered voters were less likely to have any of the acceptable forms of ID. This finding was accepted by the U.S. District Court; but the Court ruled that this was not sufficient grounds for overturning the law.

In all 3 cases the adverse impact of these laws was demonstrated based on statistical principles. This contributed to the overturning of voter ID laws in 2 of the 3 states.

Want to work with us?
You’ll be in great company.

About Us Careers

Westat Employees.
Westat Employee.
AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety
Baltimore Metropolitan Council
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning
DC Public Schools
Georgia Department of Transportation
Internal Revenue Service
Leadership Montgomery
Maryland Cancer Registry
Michigan Department of Health and Human Services
National Science Foundation
NYC Mayor’s Office for Economic Opportunity
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development
Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
SiriusXM
Social Security Administration
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration
Teach for America
Texas Education Agency
The Johns Hopkins University
The National Institutes of Health
The Verizon Foundation
Toyota
U.S. Department of Agriculture
U.S. Department of Education
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
U.S. Department of Justice
U.S. Department of Transportation
U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
University of Maryland Baltimore Campus
University of Michigan
University System of Maryland
Explore Our Clients

Please wait...

Forbes 2020 The Best Employers for Diversity Powered by Statista Copyright 2019 Forbes Media LLC. Used with permissionForbes 2019: The Best Employers for Women Powered by Statista Copyright 2019 Forbes Media LLC. Used with permission

Westat is an Equal Opportunity Employer and does not discriminate on the basis of race, creed, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, veteran status, disability, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship status, genetic information, gender identity or expression, or any other protected status under applicable law. Notices to Employees & Applicants.